Website Navigation Best Practices - 9 Navigation Design Tips and Warnings

Website Navigation Best Practices - 9 Navigation Design Tips and Warnings

Every website has a menu. But some are much better than others.

Your website navigation menu is absolutely the key to success in digital marketing. It’s one of the most important elements on your website because it affects the most important outcomes:

And if those top two factors weren’t enough, your website navigation affects virtually every other success factor of your website:

Little choices have a big impact on your results, especially for your navigation since it’s on every page of your website. So careful planning is key.

Here is a checklist for website navigation best practices. These are design ideas and tips along with examples of what to do (and what not to do) with your website’s menu.

“What we do” doesn’t actually say what you do. Neither does “Products,” “Services” or “Solutions.” Descriptive navigation that uses keyphrases is better for two reasons: rankings/traffic (SEO) and usability/conversions (UX).

Compare the difference. The first example is vague. No clarity. No differentiation. The second example is specific. Any visitor (or robot) can tell, at a glance, what the company does.

Pages with generic labels also have an SEO disadvantage. If you have one page listing all of your services, it will never rank. That’s because it’s not focusing on one specific topic. Every page on your website has a chance of ranking, as long as it’s focused on a topic, on a keyphrase.

If you’re not sure what to use, put a few possible options into Google Trends. It will show you the relative popularity of any two search terms over time. It also shows geographic differences. It’s a quick way to use keyphrase research to guide sitemap decisions.

This is why your website architecture, not just the navigation, is key for SEO. A search optimized website has a page for each service, each product, each team member and topic. Avoid making a “services” page unless there are also other, search optimized pages for each service.

Above all, it’s good for visitors.

Descriptive labels help the visitor predict what they’ll get if they click. They guide the visitor to the deeper, more specific pages.

Navigation labels tell visitors the format of the content. Other labels tell visitors the topic of the content. Here are some examples that show the difference.

It may seem natural to organize your content into formats. If you suggest it in a marketing meeting, everyone will say it makes sense. But these labels are actually not very helpful for your visitors.

Compare the difference in a navigation menu. Ask yourself which of these are more helpful to a visitor:

The difference is huge. The reason is obvious. People don’t go to websites looking for videos or whitepapers. They visit websites looking for answers and information. Imagine yourself saying:

“I want to read a whitepaper today. Any topic will do!”

Labels indicating the format aren’t descriptive and therefore, less helpful to visitors. That’s why Aurora Harley from the Nielsen Norman Group recommends against using format-based navigation.

Case studies may be the exception. When a visitor is looking for a detailed example of a problem solved, they may seek out case studies. These are a special format of bottom of funnel content and may be an effective navigation label.

Of course, case studies should also appear on the service pages for which they are relevant. Don’t just tuck them all away on one page.

Popular, yes. But not usually a great idea. Usability studies show that those little drop down menus can be frustrating.

Here’s why: visitors move their eyes much faster than they move their mouse. When they move their mouse to a menu item, they’ve already decided to click…and then you gave them more options. It’s a hiccup in the mind of the visitor. A moment of visual friction.

More importantly, drop downs encourage visitors to skip important pages. If you’re using drop downs, you can easily see this problem in your Analytics.

But the research shows that one type of drop down menu performs well in usability studies: The “mega menu” which is a very large drop down with lots of elements, almost like a mini site map. These offer so many options, making that moment of friction worth it.

If you have a big site with lots of pages and a very diverse set of products or services, a mega menu may be a good idea. Also, besides the menu itself, mega menus give you the opportunity to add descriptive text, groupings, icons, content and calls to action.

Just look at how much we fit into the mega menu on 6sense:

Visitors who are ready to reach out will look for a way to contact you in the header. It’s a common location. In fact, 55% of marketing websites have a contact button in the top right, making it a web design standard.

You can make this button more visually prominent by using a contrasting color. Take a look at the header of this global human resources website. The contact button actually says “Get Started” which is more of a call to action (CTA).

The words you choose can make a difference. Here again, specificity correlates with clickthrough rates. Specific, descriptive button labels can make a difference. Compare:

If you’d like more tips for improving clickthrough rates, we have an entire post about how to design a button.

You can use Google Optimize to run an A/B test on the clickthrough rate (CTR) of your primary call to action. Without any software or costs, you can create variants and check their performance against the original in real time.

If you’ve never seen one, here’s what a Google Optimize report looks like. We run these tests routinely as part of our website optimization service.

You’ll find more about using data to improve your website navigation in the final step below.

Some websites have literally hundreds of links on the homepage. That’s usually bad. Limiting the number of links in your main navigation is good for two reasons. These are the same two reasons to use descriptive labels:

Your homepage has the most “authority” in the eyes of a search engine. This is because more sites link to your homepage than to any of your interior pages. This authority flows to your interior pages through your navigation.

If your navigation includes 50 items and combined with every other link and button on the page, your home page links to a total of 100 pages. This means the amount of authority passed from the homepage to each of those pages is divided by 100. This is how information architecture affects SEO.

If you cut the number of links in half, you’ll double the amount of authority passed from the homepage, and increase the chance that your interior pages will rank high.

How many links are on your homepage? Check The WebFX Links Counter to find out.

The more concise your navigation, the more authority will flow to each interior page, making your interior pages more likely to rank. (Read Internal Linking Best Practices for more details)

The more items in your navigation, the more difficult the information is to scan and process for your visitors. Visually, eight is a LOT more than seven. If you have too many, visitors’ eyes may scan past important items.

If you need to use more than seven items, consider breaking them up into groups.

Tip! Each time you remove a menu item (or any other element) from a page, everything left becomes more visually prominent and is more likely to be seen and considered.

It takes discipline to make tough decisions. You can do it. Challenge yourself to trim it down to five!

The number of items matters, but so does the order of those items.

In website navigation, just like any list, items at the beginning and the end are most effective, because this is where attention and retention are highest. It’s called the serial-position effect, and it combines two cognitive biases:

For this reason, anything you put at the beginning or end of our navigation becomes more prominent. So make the most popular items or those that are most important to your business, the first or last items in the navigation.

Imagine you run a little boutique store. You hire an interior designer to spruce up the place. When they finish, you walk through the front door, excited to see the new look. And the first thing you see is …big colorful exit signs.

That’s what social media icons are: exit signs. With only a few possible exceptions, they do not belong in the header of a website. This is website navigation that reduces your traffic by suggesting the visitor leaves.

Not only are you showing them the door, you’re sending them to a place with a million distractions. The instant they click, they’ll see ads, competitors and notifications. They’ll see fun events, interesting shoes and cute kitties.

They’re not coming back. They probably forgot they were on your website.

These little icons are extremely visually prominent for three reasons: the color (high contrast), high position (top of the page) and they’re global (on every page).

Amazingly, 13% of websites still put social icons in their headers. We strongly recommend against it. Why? Because traffic is hard to win and easy to lose. And Facebook has plenty of traffic already.

So far, all of our examples have been of desktop websites. But maybe we’re looking at the wrong website? Check your Analytics to see what percentage of your visitors are looking at your mobile menu.

In Universal Analytics, the report is in Audience > Mobile > Overview. In GA4, you can find it under Reports > Tech > Tech overview. Here I’ve moved the relevant summary cards to the top.

Virtually every marketing website has a significant percentage of visitors on mobile devices. These visitors may not be as critical to business outcomes (maybe they’re mostly low-converting blog readers) but you still need an easy to use mobile menu.

This generally means a “hamburger icon” which are the three little lines in the top right of the mobile screen. Here are a few mobile navigation examples:

Tapping the hamburger icon reveals the menu, then a second tap expands the section categories.

It’s a classic responsive web design challenge to design an intuitive mobile menu. It needs to be easy for every visitor on every sized screen. This requires close collaboration between designers and programmers, followed by real-world testing.

If you’ve got a phone number in your mobile website header, visitors will expect to be able to tap to call. But web developers often miss the opportunity to make this interaction simple.

The only difference between a text phone number and a phone number you can tap to call is a tiny bit of HTML code. Here’s what that code looks like:

Designing your navigation is the beginning, not the end. Digital ink is never dry. A few weeks after creating your navigation, use Analytics to see how visitors are using it. Look for ways to improve.

It takes just a few clicks to see how visitors are using your navigation menu. Here is the process for both Universal Analytics and GA4, which we’ll all need to use starting July of 2023.

How to use Universal Analytics to measure website navigation performance:

If yours is a low traffic website, choose a longer date range. If you have a lot of items in your navigation, select 25 or 50 from the “Show rows” dropdown. Here’s what the report should look like:

Warning! Keep in mind that your home page may not be the entry point for many visitors. A search optimized website has many entry points. Many (or even most) visitors won’t start from the home page.

How to use a Google Analytics 4 (GA4) Exploration to measure website navigation performance. I’ll show this in more detail for those who aren’t yet familiar with the new version of Analytics.

Scanning through these reports, you can instantly answer all kinds of interesting and important questions:

Answering these questions is the first step in the process of analysis and improvement. Here are thoughts you might have and actions you might take

“Whoa, 20% of our visitors are looking for a job!”

…then you make a segment or filter to exclude those visitors while doing analysis for lead generation marketing.

“Wow, people really want to see our team members.”

…then you polish up those bios and start featuring your talent on your homepage.

“Hey, no one really cares about our industry pages.”

…then you turn that section into ‘case studies’ and rework the content accordingly.

The basic idea is to remove things that rarely get clicked if they aren’t important, rename them if they aren’t important, or move things around to help visitors get where they’re trying to go.

We hope these tips give you new ideas and inspiration for your menus. Ideally, you can implement your ideas quickly in your content management system. A good site is flexible, letting you adjust the labels and order of your menus in minutes.

There are exceptions to every rule. Not sure if you should make a change? Ask your web strategist to review your Analytics with you.

Images Powered by Shutterstock