#
business marketing Cookie-Cutter Marketing digital marketing

Everyone Wants to Start a Marketing Business These Days—And What That Means for Real Marketing

  • Feb 24 2025
  • .
  • by Reece Smith

The Digital Marketing Gold Rush

Lately, it feels like everyone is jumping into digital marketing. Whether it’s people looking for a side hustle, entrepreneurs, influencers, or business owners looking for an easy way to add another revenue stream, starting a marketing business is more popular than ever. And I get it—on the surface, it looks simple. Digital marketing seems like something you can easily learn, automate, scale, and turn into an easy money-maker. But in this rush to scale and make money quickly, something important is getting lost: creativity, strategy, and trust.

The problem? Digital marketing isn’t just a business model. It’s an art and a skill. It requires deep understanding, adaptability, and, most importantly, a human touch. But today, everyone is treating it like a formula they can apply to any business, slap on some ads, and call it a day. And that’s why so much of today’s marketing feels uninspired and ineffective.

The Rise of Cookie-Cutter Marketing

A lot of these so-called marketing businesses rely on the same pre-made templates and automated processes. Instead of taking the time to understand each client’s business, audience, and goals, they push out the same cookie-cutter strategies for every client. And here’s the issue: real marketing isn’t plug-and-play.

Think about it. If every business were truly the same, marketing wouldn’t even be necessary. Customers could just pick whatever shows up first. But that’s not how people make decisions. Marketing should be about helping brands stand out, not blend in. Instead, these mass-market approaches are stripping away uniqueness, reducing brands to nothing more than generic messages that lack authenticity.

Automation has its place, but when marketing is only about automation, the results are robotic and lifeless. Strategy takes a backseat. Brand identity disappears. And instead of making businesses more competitive, these templated solutions make them indistinguishable from their competitors.

The Trust Issue: Why Real Relationships Matter

One of the biggest casualties of this mass-produced marketing approach is that it kills trust. The best marketing comes from actually knowing your clients—their industry, their challenges, their goals. But when agencies don’t take the time to dig deep, their work feels generic and out of touch.

Businesses that invest in these automated solutions quickly realize something’s off. Their marketing doesn’t speak their language. It doesn’t reflect their values. And worst of all, it doesn’t resonate with their customers. Why? Because it was never truly made for them in the first place.

Clients notice when they’re just another name on a list. They don’t feel heard, they don’t feel understood, and they definitely don’t feel confident in the marketing strategy they’re paying for. And let’s be real—when trust is gone, so is the business relationship. That’s why so many clients bounce from agency to agency, constantly searching for someone who actually gets them.

The Impact: When ‘Marketing’ Becomes a Commodity

Because marketing businesses are popping up everywhere, marketing itself is starting to feel like just another commodity. It’s no longer about strategy or creative execution—it’s just another service people are selling. The result?

– More agencies offering cheap, ineffective marketing that doesn’t drive results.

– Businesses struggling to tell the difference between legit experts and people
just trying to cash in.

– A market flooded with cookie-cutter campaigns that all look and feel the same.

The worst part? Bad marketing makes people think marketing doesn’t work. When businesses don’t see results, they assume marketing itself is the problem—not the quality of the marketing they’re getting. And that’s dangerous. It makes business owners skeptical of investing in marketing at all, even when they actually need it to grow.

The Alternative: Quality Over Scalability

So, what’s the solution? It’s not about rejecting scalability altogether—I’m all for efficiency. But there’s a right way to do it. The best marketing businesses scale without sacrificing quality, creativity, and relationships.

That means:

– Taking the time to actually understand each client’s industry and goals.

– Customizing strategies instead of copy-pasting templates.

– Using automation wisely, but never at the expense of originality.

– Building real relationships with clients, so they know you’re invested in their success.

This is what separates real marketers from those just trying to make a quick buck. Marketing is about creativity, psychology, and communication—not just slapping together some ads and calling it a day.

The Future of Digital Marketing

AI and automation aren’t going anywhere, and I’m not saying they’re all bad. But businesses need to be smart about how they use them. The brands that win will be the ones that invest in creativity, authenticity, and trust.

If you’re looking for marketing support, here’s my advice: choose your marketing partners wisely. Don’t just go for the cheapest or most scalable option—go for the one that actually understands your business and will take the time to get things right. Because at the end of the day, scalability should never replace strategy, relationships, and creativity.

That’s the difference between just selling marketing—and actually making marketing work.

Reece Smith
About Reece Smith

As a results-driven marketing and entrepreneurship professional, I’ve built my career at the intersection of creativity, strategy, and innovation. With a BA in Business Administration and a minor in Mass Communications, my journey began before I graduated by helping my mother grow her digital marketing agency, where I gained invaluable experience and discovered a passion for driving business success. Graduating in May of 2020 during an uncertain time taught me resilience and adaptability, qualities that have shaped my approach to leadership and problem-solving. Marketing and entrepreneurship are extraordinary forces that shape industries, create opportunities, and connect people in meaningful ways. They hold the power to turn ideas into action and generate measurable impact. What inspires me most is the ability to craft strategies and solutions that drive growth and improve lives. This passion led me to connect with gotcha! as a partner, where I was so inspired by the company’s vision and innovation that I joined the gotcha! family. Today, I am proud to contribute my expertise and leadership to an organization dedicated to reshaping the digital marketing landscape. Outside of work, I prioritize balance and personal growth. I enjoy spending time with my two Labrador retrievers, my cat, and my fiancé. Family is central to my life, whether it’s with my sisters, niece, brother-in-law, parents, or my fiancé’s family. My hobbies include golfing, boating, beach outings, working out, bowling, and cheering on the Florida Gators in football and basketball. Staying active and fostering meaningful relationships mirror my professional commitment to growth and connection.

Related Posts

related post
business marketing Cookie-Cutter Marketing digital marketing

Storytelling in Branding: Creating Emotional Connections

I recently read Start With Why by Simon Sinek, and it completely shifted my perspective on branding. One of the key takeaways from the book is that people don’t buy...

  • Mar 03, 2025
  • .
  • by Marija Vidanovic
related post
business marketing Cookie-Cutter Marketing digital marketing

Stop Selling: The Key to Marketing Success in Today’s World

In the fast-paced, ever-evolving landscape of modern marketing, one principle stands out as a game-changer: stop selling. This may seem counterintuitive. After all, isn’t the entire purpose of marketing to...

  • Feb 03, 2025
  • .
  • by Reece Smith
related post
business marketing Cookie-Cutter Marketing digital marketing

The Power of Creating a Website with a Strong Funnel

In today’s digital-first world, having a website is no longer optional for businesses—it’s a necessity. But simply having a website isn’t enough. To truly succeed, your website needs to be...

  • Jan 20, 2025
  • .
  • by Reece Smith